Skip to content
OUR MARKET IS CLOSED | THANK YOU FOR 2 YEARS OF VOTING WITH YOUR DOLLARS
OUR MARKET IS CLOSED | THANK YOU FOR 2 YEARS OF VOTING WITH YOUR DOLLARS

The Punchy Cat

Founded by Molly Freeman, The Punchy Cat is an Iowa City-based brand that creates quirky, handmade cat toys.
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Witch Hat

    $10.00

    Made to order!  Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will love this Halloween themed catnip witch hat toy! Approximately 3.5” This super pote...

    View full details
  • Sold out
    The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Pumpkin Hat

    $10.00

    Made to order!  Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will love this Halloween themed catnip jack-o-lantern hat toy! Approximately 3.5” This s...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Twin Cherries Catnip Toy

    $10.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. Your kitty will perk up for this cutie fruity cherry design! 4” twin cherries catnip toy This super potent ca...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Moon

    $10.00

    Made to order!  Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will love this mystical crescent moon catnip toy! Approximately 4” This super potent cat...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Dorito Chip

    $7.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. You and your cat will get a good chuckle over this realistic looking Dorito catnip chip! 3” hand painted Dorit...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Rainbow Cloud Cat Toy

    $9.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will love this cheerful cat toy. 3.75" x 5" catnip rainbow cloud  This super potent cat toy...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Twinkle

    $10.00

    Made to order!  Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will love this golden twinkle star catnip toy! Approximately 4.5” This super potent cat ...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Carrot

    $9.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. Your kitty will love this cute orange carrot!  6” orange and green felt catnip carrot This super potent cat to...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Snake

    $14.00

    Made to order!  Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will love this slithery snake friend!  9” green snake with braided red yarn tongue. This...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Cookie Cat Toy

    $9.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. Your won't be able to resist this sweet little cookie toy! 2.75” chocolate chip cookie catnip toy This super p...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Smiley Face

    $10.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. You and your kitties won't be able to contain the joy when you see (and sniff) this happy smiley face cat toy!...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Catnip Worm

    $14.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will love this funny pink worm friend!  9” pink worm with hand painted red markings This s...

    View full details
  • The Punchy Cat

    Fried Egg Catnip Toy

    $8.00

    Made to order! Ships within 1 week. You and your kitty will flip for this sunny side up fried egg catnip toy! 4” fried egg catnip toy This super p...

    View full details